Young people who commit serious crimes such as robbery should be punished as adults. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
【句子示例】 It sounds logical that stiff punishment for juvenile offenders may act as a deterrent against heinous crimes, prompting young people to carefully consider the consequences before committing an offense.
【解析】 1. 内容维度(Task Response) 这个句子分析了严厉的惩罚(stiff punishment)对于青少年罪犯有可能起到威慑的作用(act as a deterrent),因为严厉的惩罚能迫使年轻人在犯罪之前考虑后果。
2. 文脉逻辑维度(Coherence and Cohesion) 本句话之后写作者可以考虑对比“轻判”的后果,例如社区服务community service这样的判决方式可能带来的问题:犯罪代价太低则无法抑制严重的青少年犯罪。当然,后面的段落可以尝试证明“虽然青少年的重罪犯人应该重判,但是惩罚力度和成年人仍然有区别”,比如死刑或者无期一般不适用于青少年。
4. 语法和句型维度(Grammatical Range and Accuracy) 本句中it是形式主义,真正的主语内容是that后面引导的从句stiff punishment for juvenile offenders may act as a deterrent against heinous crimes,句意为:对青少年罪犯进行严厉惩罚有可能对严重的犯罪起到威慑作用。句子主干后面prompting young people to...是现在分词的使用,进一步解释了严厉惩罚stiff punishment带来的效果,即:迫使年轻人在实施犯罪之前考虑后果。